Fire Island Pines holiday rentals are £1,194/night on average. However, you may find that prices fluctuate depending on the time of year. For example, June is the most expensive month to book a holiday rental in Fire Island Pines, and May is often the cheapest month to book. Recently, our users found rentals for £208/night - which is currently the cheapest price. Keep in mind that anything £995/night or less is still considered a good deal.