Among The Trees, Minutes From Liberty Mtn. Resort And 10 Miles From Gettysburg is a very popular hotel in Carroll Valley, with a score of 10.0 from 17 reviews. Hampton Inn Gettysburg (9.1 from 207 reviews) and The Inn at White Oak (9.8 from 155 reviews) are also highly rated Carroll Valley hotels based on recent feedback from HotelsCombined users.